The Christian Higher Education Innovation Alliance (CHEIA) is a collaboration of leaders to support the global growth of post-secondary education serving the majority world and the poor
Dual Transformation from MOOC’s 1.0 to MOOC’s 2.0
As many of you know, in the past few years City Vision University has launched three MOOC courses through Udemy as a part of what I (Andrew Sears) call our MOOC 1.0 experiment. Several others on the CHEIA list helped me develop two of the courses: Mike Truong, Amanda Forbes and Jay Gary.
The dominant model we were following in developing these courses was Dual Transformation (see diagram above). Here are some of the lessons I feel like we learned in our MOOC 1.0 experiment.
- To date we had 13,665 enrollments. Completion rates were low similar to other MOOCs, but I don’t view that as a bad thing.
- Dual transformation probably is the best model to think about disruption in regulated industries like Higher Education, but the key to get it to work is item C-capabilities link shown above.
- Essentially, what we did in our experiment was that our Transformation A and Transformation B were essentially misaligned. Our Transformation A focused on City Vision’s core competencies in Nonprofit Management & Addiction Counseling. Our Transformation B focused on a core competency in Innovative Online/Blended Education. The problem was that these were essentially two different markets, so we could not really build much of a capabilities link C between them. Ultimately this meant that the 1.0 MOOCs were not sustainable outside of grant funding because they did not produce a revenue stream.
- While we did get similar versions of these courses accredited, we actually never launched them because there was not an effective capabilities link.
- While Udemy was great for boosting numbers (which foundations like), they ultimately own the customer, so we never had email addresses. Ultimately, this severely limited our ability to convert Udemy students into paying students. In addition, Udemy recently pivoted to deprioritize free courses and limit their length to 2 hours of video, which is problematic.
- We were ultimately able to fund the development of these courses through grants and just donating our own time. Probably the most significant problem is that the halflife of most courses in 3 to 5 years, so unless there is an ongoing revenue stream, then it will not be financially sustainable to continue to update the courses.
This leads me to announcing our MOOC 2.0 experiment. City Vision University has just launched our City Vision Institute as our MOOC 2.0 experiment. The goal of the City Vision Institute is to provide Free Online Courses for Nonprofit and Ministry Leaders (http://institute.cityvision.edu). Here is what we are doing differently this time based on the lessons we learned:
- We are running the courses on Learndash in WordPress. This gives us a lot more control and allows us to essentially provide free MOOCs as a form of the freemium business model or content marketing since students provide email addresses in registering.
- We decided to focus our future courses around the core competencies of City Vision University so our content marketing efforts are attracting the type of people who may one day be students with us.
- When we do develop new courses or major redesigns of courses, we will identify some where we design them both in our LMS and in Learndash simultaneously.
- Students from the MOOC can pay $100 to get credit. For this to work with our accreditor, we essentially had to provide all the same assignments in a comprehensive workbook that students can submit to be assessed later. We limit this price to their first course, so we do not undercut our pricing for regular students.
- Ultimately, the most important part of this experiment is whether the freemium business model is self-sustaining on an ongoing basis. Ultimately, to continue to update courses, we have to be able to pay our cost to do that. While we could try to continue to be grant based, I’m skeptical whether that is viable long-term.
We will keep you all posted on how this next experiment goes.
Coronavirus COVID-19 Resources for Christian Schools Going Online
Get the latest version of this document in this Open Google Doc.
Why Schools are Closing
- Coronavirus: Why You Must Act Now. Politicians, Community Leaders and Business Leaders: What Should You Do and When?. The above article is the most comprehensive source of data I’ve seen on understanding why school closings are important. It has had over 24 million views in 72 hours and has been translated into 19 languages.
Online Education Resources & Advice (also applies to k-12)
- Educause COVID-19: Probably the best resource currently available for schools
- OLC Continuity Planning and Emergency Preparedness – OLC. Great resource.
- Edsurge: Navigating Uncertain Times: How Schools Can Cope With Coronavirus. Great resource.
- 10 Strategies for Leading Online When School is Closed. Great resource.
- 16 Free Resources for Schools Who are Closing Due to Coronavirus Great resource.
- Six Steps to Successfully Begin Teaching Online: A Beginner’s Guide For Those Forced Into Online Teaching
- Coronavirus Has Led to a Rush of Online Teaching. Here’s Some Advice for Newly Remote Instructors
- The COVID-19 online pivot
- Emergencies and Switching to Online Learning
- Inside Higher Ed LIVE UPDATES: Latest news on coronavirus and higher education
- Chronicle of Higher Education Coronavirus Hits Campus
Teacher Training Resources
Model Campus Responses to Train Faculty & Others
- Rapid Online Teaching Resources | Adams Center
- APU: Coronavirus (COVID-19) Information and Guidelines
- GCU Coronavirus Disease 2019 Information | GCU
Podcasts & Videos
- Future U. Episode 50: Managing Campuses During the Coronavirus. Provides good advice for administrators
- ICETE Academy: Video 1, Video 2, Video 3, Video 4. Advice for theological schools.
Technology Resources
- Remote learning with Khan Academy during school closures
- Free Tools for Schools Dealing with Corona
- Coronavirus Tech Deals
- www.zoom.com (best cloud based multi-person video conference)
- screencast-o-matic.com (best affordable screen recording software)
- International Educator Shared resources for virtual learning in emergency
- http://www.amazingeducationalresources.com
Communities
Resources from Learning Management System Vendors
- Tools for Online Learning when the Classroom Closes | Canvas Learning Platform
- Our Commitment To You During Coronavirus | Canvas E-Learning
- Blackboard Webinar – Preparing to scale online teaching and learning during Coronavirus
Legal Guidance
- Click here to read an analysis from CooleyEd on Managing COVID-19 Disruption
- Click here to read an analysis from CooleyED on this USED communication
- Click here to read the announcement from the United States Department of Education (USED) regarding COVID-19 guidance
- Click here to read an analysis from Hogan Lovells on this USED communication
Resources for Christian K-12 Schools
Resources for Parents of k-12 Schools Closing
- ‘Classroom to Cloud’: What happened when coronavirus forced my kid’s school to go online
- Low Income Internet Service Providers – $5 a month
Public Health Recommendations for k-12 Schools
Academic Program Development and Accreditation Course
This is a part of a 4 course series supported by CHEIA.
Course Links and Description
- Course on Udemy
- YouTube Playlist for this Course. This playlist includes all the Udemy videos used in this course as well as supplemental YouTube videos referenced in this course.
- SlideShare Presentation for this Course.
- Bibliography for this Course in Zotero. This is largely a list of additional books that may be of interest to students.
This is a project-based course where the finished project will be develop an academic program. In this course you will learn to:
- Design courses in Udemy (or in an unaccredited organization) for academic credit
- Design an effective higher education academic degree or certificate program
- Collect stakeholder feedback and conduct online research of similar programs to determine effective program design
- Develop program outcomes and an outcome map to courses
- Develop values integration for those in Christian higher education, ministry, missions agency or churches providing high-quality unaccredited, semi-accredited and non-formal education
- Apply lean startup principles and agile methods to academic program design to adapt to resource-constrained environments
- Complete the documentation needed to submit an academic program for review to an accreditor (or design program documentation to support alternative methods to accreditation in contexts where that is needed)
This course builds on our first course Disruptive Innovation in Higher Education in Udemy and iTunes U, which now has had over 5,000 students. That course looked at the disruptive innovation challenge where higher education globally is expanding from 100 million students in 2000 to 263 million by 2025. While that course was focused on vision and strategy, this course is a very practical follow-up.
Continue reading “Academic Program Development and Accreditation Course”Instructional Design for Online and Blended Learning Course
This is a part of a 4 course series supported by CHEIA.
Course Links and Description
In this course, you will complete the design of an online or blended course using best practices through the following steps:
- Use our template to conduct analysis, research and planning for your course.
- Design learning outcomes and use our template to design a course introduction and syllabus to meet accreditation standards.
- Design each week of your course using our course blueprint template and use the OSCQR rubric to evaluate your course for best practices.
- Design using latest technology, videos and screencasts to improve the engagement of your course.
- Develop and publish your course in Canvas (or other system) based on the course blueprint you designed.
- For those who come from Christian institutions, you will apply best practices to integrate a Christian worldview into course design.
This course builds on our first course Disruptive Innovation in Higher Education in Udemy and iTunes U, which now has had over 5,000 students. That course looked at the disruptive innovation challenge where higher education globally is expanding from 100 million students in 2000 to 263 million by 2025. While that course was focused on vision and strategy, this course is a very practical follow-up.
This course will be co-taught by myself and Dr. Michael Truong, who helps train others in instructional design principles at Azusa Pacific University, one of the largest Christian universities in America. We both also serve as co-founders of the Christian Higher Education Innovation Alliance, which sponsored this course.
There are several things that make this course unique compared to other instructional design courses.
- First, this course is designed around constructivist learning philosophy so that you will learn instructional design through building a course.
- Second, this course will provide very practical creative commons worksheets and templates for you to use and reuse in building your courses. We designed this course so that smaller schools could use this course or the templates we provide as a faculty training program for smaller institutions to equip their faculty to design online and blended courses
- Third, this Udemy course has the exact same materials as the accredited Instructional Design course provided by City Vision University, and we are giving it away for free.
Disruptive Innovation in Christian Higher Education Course
This is a part of a 4 course series supported by CHEIA.
Course Links and Description
This course provides the latest expertly curated materials on this topic by a university president focused on disruptive innovation who spent years developing them. I (Andrew Sears) have tried to curate the “best of the best” of materials in this field including: unbundling universities, unbundling faculty, online education, emerging markets, Base of the Pyramid strategy, Lean Startup for education, Blue Ocean Strategy for education, accreditation, for profits and MOOCs and examining implications for specific markets like faith-based/Christian higher education.
After completing this course, you should be able to:
1) explain how the forces of disruptive innovation are affecting their organization’s context,
2) apply models such as Lean Startup, Blue Ocean Canvas, Porter’s Five Forces and the Dual Transformation model to their organization’s context, 3) develop a strategy presentation on how their institution should respond to the forces of disruptive innovation using the Dual Transformation model and other models.
The course has had over 5,000 students from 126 different countries.
Course Materials
Lesson 1. Course Introduction
- View Videos and Assignments for This Lesson on Udemy
- Course Playlist in YouTube
- Course in iTunes University
- Course Slides on Slideshare
Lesson 2. Disruptive Innovation Theory Applied to Higher Education
- View Videos and Assignments for This Lesson on Udemy
- Clayton Christensen on Disruptive Innovation and Higher Education
- Michael Horn on Disrupting Class
- Bibliography for this section
Lesson 3. Understanding What’s Driving Change in Traditional Higher Education
- Michael Raynor on The Strategy Paradox: Why committing to success leads to failure
- Michael Horn on Blended Learning as a Sustaining Innovation
- Bibliography for this section
- Goldie Blumenstyk on The Cost of College (The Chronicle of Higher Education)
- Salman Khan: The One World Schoolhouse: Education Reimagined
Lesson 4. Market Dynamics of Online Education
- Online College Students 2015 Market Research Webinar
- Five Keys to Enrolling in a Crowded Online Market Learning House Presentation
- Online Education Bibliography
- 2014 Babson Survey of Online Education “Grade Level: Tracking Online Education in the United States”
- Market Dynamics of Traditional Online Education
Lesson 5. Innovative Models for Blending Unaccredited and Accredited Education
Lesson 6. Disruptive Innovation in Christian Higher Education
Lesson 7. Disruptive Innovation and Crossing the Chasm
Lesson 8. Emerging Markets and Bottom of the Pyramid Strategy
- Thomas Friedman | Globalization of Higher Education
- Globalization of Higher Education Conference by Academic Partnerships
- Global Higher Education Bibliography
- Disruptive Innovation in Education for Emerging Markets and Courseware Platforms.ENCODING.mp4
- Jugaad Innovation: Jaideep Prabhu at TEDxUCL
- Ted London – Business opportunities at the Base of the Pyramid
- C. K. Prahalad on the Fortune at the Bottom of the Pyramid
- City Vision University’s $2,000 Associate’s and $5,000 Bachelor’s Degree
- Abhinav Mital: Strategies for Success in Emerging Education Markets
- Bibliography for Emerging Markets and BoP Strategy
Lesson 9. Unbundling and Rebundling Strategies in Higher Education
- Michael Staton Paper: Disaggregating the Components of a College Degree
- Ryan Craig Podcast on His Book College Disrupted: The Great Unbundling of Higher Education
- Bibliography on Unbundling in higher Education
- Michael Stanton on Unbundling Education Google Hangout
- Jeffrey Selingo, on The Coming Disruption: The Unbundling of American Education (Chronicle of Higher Education)
- Albert Wenger on Unbundling Higher Education
Lesson 10. Unbundling & the Changing Role of Faculty
- Erik Brynjolfsson: The key to growth? Race with the machines TED Talk
- Yochai Benkler: Open-source economics TED Talk
- Reid Hoffman & Ben Casnocha: The Startup of You
- Reid Hoffman: The Alliance: Managing Talent in the Networked Age
- Michael Hyatt: How to Build Your Platform in 30 Minutes a Day
- Daniel Pink: A Whole New Mind
- Bibliography on Unbundling Faculty
Lesson 11. Lean Startup Methodology for Education
Lesson 12. Demographic and Economic Trend Analysis for Higher Education
- View Videos and Assignments for This Lesson on Udemy
- Bibliography for Demographic and Economic Trend Analysis for Higher Education
Lesson 13. Access, the Opportunity Divide & the Race Between Technology and Education
- Bibliography for Access, the Opportunity Divide & the Race Between Technology and Education
- Tom Mortenson: The Impact of Financial Decisions on Access and Opportunity: Radio Higher Ed Podcast
Lesson 14. Industry Case Study and Media Ecology Lessons for Faculty & Higher Education
Lesson 15. Change Agents and Diffusion of Innovation
How to Do Effective Christian Higher Education in an Unbundled World?
Continue reading “How to Do Effective Christian Higher Education in an Unbundled World?”
Gartner Hype Cycle and Christian Higher Education
Every year Gartner publishes its Hype Cycle of Education. For 2016, we have invited members of CHEIA to post their reflections on this hype cycle for Christian Higher Education. Here they are: Continue reading “Gartner Hype Cycle and Christian Higher Education”